Hyolyn’s Latest Comeback Sparks Massive Debate About “Stealing Culture” And “Copying” Tyla
Hyolyn recently teased her new track, “Wait.” The energetic beats and twerking dance moves immediately became a hot topic online. The full MV was released on August 12, 2024.
HYOLYN(효린) 'Wait' MV Teaserhttps://t.co/v2yhDSf2FK
2024.08.12 6PM(KST)
I’ve been waiting too long 👋#HYOLYN #효린 #Wait #8월12일 #놀러올래 #Waitisland #웨잇 pic.twitter.com/BelNtaq1BC— 🌊Hyolyn is back⛱️ (@xhyolynx05) August 9, 2024
She soon went viral for another reason. Some international netizens found that the beats and the dance moves were strikingly similar to that of Tyla‘s.
Tyla has her first son https://t.co/XbqszYsUXo pic.twitter.com/BUksIqaWAX
— Siya (@SiyaSomething) August 12, 2024
In particular, many referenced her hit song “Water,” claiming that “Water” led to many similar dances in South Korea.
tyla sunbaeminnn https://t.co/nGT1pGEvbJ
— ᕙ༆ministra do tesão༆ᕗ (@aneisdenetuno_) August 13, 2024
Others fought back, arguing that Hyolyn has done this style of choreography and music since her earlier days.
“not one original idea” “tyla you will always be famous” yall sound so fucking stupid hyolyn has been doing that for YEARS !!! https://t.co/EMJynGVqtR
— ً aj JAEM DAY!¡ (@lmksbf) August 12, 2024
In retrospect, Tyla was born in 2002, while “Water” was released in 2024. Hyolyn premiered her sexy hit “Dally” in 2018, the song and choreography that had many concerned for how sexual it was.
when tyla was in high school hyolyn was out on korean national tv pissing christians off with her choreos. hyolyn has been doing this before tyla even released her first song 😭 https://t.co/9zUpkIfuUh
— sebby; 💙 (@h0tmez) August 12, 2024
Some netizens went as far as to accuse Hyolyn of stealing from Tyla’s culture.
Those are Afrobeats, tyla grew up with it cause it’s her culture, hyolyn was doing what kpop does best which is steal whatever is trendy from other cultures
— 〄ⵜⵉⵍⴻⵍⵉ〄 (@doudousgagas) August 13, 2024
Don’t disrespect Tyla. Hyolyn has been using music from Tyla’s culture and black American culture for years. I wouldn’t say stole it. Hyolyn definitely appears to appreciate the culture. But let’s be real, she is borrowing from music and dances that are Tyla’s birthright.
— Tristan 🫧 😋 (@Khushrenda13) August 13, 2024
Many argued that while Tyla performing to afrobeats and dancing Bacardi is part of her birth right, Hyolyn’s recent comeback seemed to be highly inspired by Tyla’s recent international acclaim and popularity. Although Hyolyn’s previous works had showcased similarly provocative dance moves, her music had been leaning more towards an R&B style.
Catch “Wait” below.