BTS Jin’s Comments About K-Pop Idols Debuting Too Young Has Unfortunately Become Reality

He is rightly concerned.

BTS‘s Jin replied to a fan comment about trying to get into the K-Pop industry that left fans discussing the age K-Pop idols are now debuting at.

The fan has been auditioning for a lot of different K-Pop companies, but hasn’t had any luck getting through any of them. She said that the companies are telling her that she’s trying to get into the industry too late — despite the fact that she was born in 2003, making her only 17 or 18 years old at the time of her comment.

Back in the third-generation and early fourth-generation eras of K-Pop, this likely wouldn’t have been an issue at all. There are many very successful K-Pop idols still active today — such as Red Velvet‘s IreneWendy, and SeulgiMAMAMOO‘s Solar and MoonbyulNCT‘s TaeyongDoyoungYuta, and Taeil, and even BTS’s SugaJ-Hope, and Jin themselves — that debuted between the ages of 19-21, showing that an idol can be successful even if their career only begins after they’ve become an adult. Specifically, Irene debuted when she was 23!

Red Velvet’s Irene

These days, however, some idols are debuting at shockingly young ages. For example, LIGHTSUM‘s JianTRI.BE‘s Mire, and Billie‘s Haruna were all born in 2006, making them all just 15 or younger at the time of their debut. And they aren’t exceptions — many other members of these and other rookie groups were born in 2005 or 2004, meaning that they likely started their trainee period in their pre-teen years or earlier.

TRI.BE’s Mire

P Nation was criticized due to the ages of the trainees in their upcoming boy group, including one member, Kiko, born in 2009, making him just 12 years old during the show. Some of the contestants on the competition show My Teenage Girl were also only 10-12 years old.

P Nation trainee Kiko

Most recently, Universe Ticket announced the eight members who would comprise of the group UNIS, and the group included a 12-year-old, Seowon, as well as two 14-year-olds.

Jin’s response to the comment from the fan shows how he feels about the seemingly ever-decreasing age that kids are allowed to start being a trainee and debut in K-Pop.

I got in at 20 years old. But I think that kids these days do start too young.

— Jin

His comment has sparked a lot of conversation among fans who were also concerned about the young age that idols are debuting at these days, including the struggle these kids have lacking real-world experience, the possibility of exploitation, and not allowing them to have a “real” childhood.

  • “Younger trainers does not equal better. It opens the doors to more exploitation, and abuse because a child isn’t going to be able to stand up for themselves.”
  • “I also do think that kids under 16/18 shouldnt be in training either seeing how gruesome and unhealthy some companies treat these kids. i mean, dieting, losing weight, skipping meals, excessive exertion during your early teens is bound to have derogative mental and physical impacts on the kids bodies as well.”
  • “I think we can see how that can shape one’s life, as Taemin had a hard time when he enlisted and JK has repeatedly said that he doesn’t know how not to be BTS’s Jungkook, since their life has been revolving around performing. I think that it hinders their growth as human being since they don’t know how to be their own self, rather than what the industry wants them to be, which is a trend that you can also see in child star.”
  • “Taemin’s talked about a lot of things that he went through because he debuted too young. I’m glad Jin is bringing this up because no matter how much fans oppose it, nothing’s gonna change unless people in positions of power speak up too.”
My Teenage Girl
Jungkook around the time he debuted

Whatever the reasoning is for companies to debut idols at younger ages — be it a longer time for them to be in their “best” years, appealing to younger audiences, or something else — many fans seem to agree that something should be changed so that these young children don’t get taken advantage of in their pursuit of their dreams.